DRUGSTORE LASHES ARE ONLY CHEAP IF YOU WEAR THEM TWICE

At $9 a pair, drugstore lashes become expensive fast — if you wear them once and throw them away. The good news? That same pair can last 15 wears. I know because I've done it, and I'm the person who once glued her eyelid shut in a rush.

I USED TO THROW AWAY $9 LASHES AFTER ONE WEAR

I used to rip my lashes off at the end of the night, peel the glue off with my fingers, and toss them in the trash by morning. Then I met a lash artist who showed me a better way. Her secret? It's not about being careful. It's about having a tiny routine.

My first attempt still went wrong. I scrubbed too hard, the fibers clumped, and the band bent like a noodle. But once I got the steps right, the same $9 pair looked gorgeous for over a month.

HOW TO CLEAN DRUGSTORE LASHES IN 6 MINUTES OR LESS

1. Peel gently with tweezers. Lift from the outer corner, never the middle.
2. Soak in warm water with mild soap. Let them sit for 90 seconds. This dissolves the glue without you scrubbing.
3. Swish, don't scrub. Run a cotton swab along the band to roll off leftover glue.
4. Blot dry with a paper towel. Press softly. Never twist or pull.
5. Reshape the curl. Wrap the lashes around a small pill bottle overnight.
6. Store them in the original tray. Loose lashes lose their shape within two days.

WHY MOST PEOPLE RUIN THEIR LASHES IN ONE NIGHT

If you've tried to reuse lashes and failed, you're not clumsy. These three mistakes are behind almost every ruined pair I've seen:

• Peeling the band off with your fingers, which stretches the corners.
• Wiping lashes with makeup remover wipes, which clumps and weakens the fibers.
• Flattening them on a tissue to dry, which kills the curl.

Avoid those, and one mid-range drugstore pair can genuinely last 10 to 15 wears.

QUICK COMPARISON: LASH CLEANING METHODS

Method	Time	Damage Risk	Result
Warm water + mild soap soak	3 minutes	Low	Clean, flexible band
Oil-based makeup remover	5 minutes	Medium	Clean but loosens the band
Picking off glue with fingers	1 minute	High	Rips fibers, bends the band

REUSING DRUGSTORE LASHES: YOUR QUESTIONS ANSWERED

HOW MANY TIMES CAN YOU REUSE DRUGSTORE LASHES?

With proper cleaning and storage, most quality drugstore lashes can be reused 5 to 15 times. The band will eventually lose its flexibility after weeks of regular wear.

WHAT IS THE BEST WAY TO REMOVE LASH GLUE WITHOUT RUINING THE BAND?

Soak the lash in warm soapy water for 90 seconds, then roll the glue off with a cotton swab. Never pull or scrape — that weakens the band and causes fiber loss.

HOW DO YOU RESTORE CURVED LASHES AFTER CLEANING?

Wrap the clean lashes around a cylindrical object, like a makeup brush handle or a pill bottle, and let them sit overnight. The fibers will reshape to the curve.

IS IT SAFE TO SHARE REUSABLE LASHES WITH A FRIEND?

No. Even after cleaning, sharing lashes can transfer bacteria to your eyes. Keep your lashes for your eyes only.

WHAT TO LOOK FOR IN A LASH THAT CAN TAKE THE REUSE

Not every pair survives the cleaning ritual. In my testing, the lashes that last the longest have a flexible cotton band, tapered fiber tips, and tight knots that don't shed.

When a lash ticks those boxes, the savings add up fast. One $9 pair reused 12 times is seventy-five cents a wear. That's the outcome that matters — beautiful eyes without throwing money into the trash.

That's the standard I look for in every lash I recommend, and it's why PHANSTA LASHES became my go-to. Their strip lashes are built to be worn again and again, so you get the look without the waste.

📚 Browse our complete library of lash guides →